There’s never been any great secret to the business case for self-checkout kiosks. With a conventional checkout, the staff to customer/transaction ratio is one-to-one: a cashier can only serve one customer and process one sale at any one time.
But with self-checkout, that ratio goes up significantly in favour of transactions. One member of staff can manage several self-checkout terminals at once, significantly increasing throughput while reducing the number of cashiers required.
However, as many leading supermarket chains have started to learn the hard way, there is a limit to how far you can push this logic before the benefits start to erode. Many big operators have seen self-checkout as an opportunity to drastically cut back on cashier numbers and therefore reduce labour costs. But the result has been a deterioration in service and a spike in shrinkage that has all but swept those cost benefits away.
The emerging consensus is that looking at self-checkout purely through a lens of labour savings is self-defeating. Businesses instead need to take a more nuanced and holistic view about how self-checkout fits into their operations. In doing that, the calculation about the benefits of self-checkout shifts from labour savings to labour optimisation.
Self-checkout might reduce the need for dedicated cashiers, but that’s not the same as reducing total staff numbers. Employees are still needed to approve age-restricted purchases, resolve weight and bagging-area alerts, assist with mis-scans and correct product selection or payment errors. They may also have to remove security tags and, in grocery, carry out age verification for restricted items.
All of this can keep a member of staff allocated to the self-checkout area very busy. If you don’t get the staff-to-terminals ratio right, it’s easy for employees to get overwhelmed at busy times.
Research by ECR Retail Loss highlights the importance of these ratios. The most common arrangement reported was one employee supervising five or six self-checkouts. However, 53% of employees surveyed said that four machines was the maximum optimum number to manage effectively, compared to 31% who said five or six and 16% who thought seven or more was manageable.
In practice, 38% of respondents had responsibility for at least seven machines. A quarter said they could not effectively monitor all the self-checkouts allocated to them, while 38% said they could only cope when the area was not busy.
The consequences of employees struggling to manage too many self-checkout kiosks at once can be serious. Alerts take longer to resolve, customers are left waiting and employees become trapped in reactive troubleshooting. YouGov found that 27% of British adults had been annoyed by self-checkouts during the previous 12 months. The much-publicised unpopularity of self-checkout can be directly attributed to inadequate oversight and staffing.
An even bigger problem is the rise in shrinkage associated with self-checkout. Studies have shown that average shrink rates in retail increase by 22% in the first year after self-checkout is introduced. Again, this is an oversight problem. Overstretched staff cannot keep up with accidental mis-scans and suspicious behaviour, and thieves will take advantage of knowing they are not being monitored properly.
The answer is to change the thinking around how self-checkout can save a business money. Instead of asking how few people can supervise a self-checkout area, retailers should be asking what staffing levels will allow the technology and the wider team to deliver the optimum productivity.
There is no single correct ratio. The right level of coverage depends on the number of terminals, footfall, basket sizes, and the nature of the items being scanned. It will change drastically from quiet to peak periods. Staffing ratios may therefore need to change throughout the day.
Store layout, security protocols and local shrink risks must also be considered. The reliability of the system and how easy the interface is to use also makes a difference. Simple, user-friendly kiosks that scan items and process sales accurately without regular glitches ease the load on employees.
Get all of these things right, and put in place plans so staff oversight can adjust flexibly with demand, and self-checkout can not only boost sales throughput, but it can release staff capacity elsewhere in the store. That’s where the wider labour benefit lies.